 In the summer of 2007, five esteemed Gramophone critics - Rob Cowan, Jed Distler, Lindsay Kemp, Patrick O’Connor and Peter Quantrill - were given the task of unearthing their favourite treasures, that by the plethora of discs currently on the market, they felt had been unfairly overlooked. It is a momentous task and but I would imagine a hugely enjoyable one. In line with the interesting and slightly different website that we try to be, we thought you'd like to know what they chose. Unfortunately a fair number of their choices are no longer available, but the ones that are you'll find below - I suppose a sort of 'alternative essential collection'. |
 Scriabin: Orchestral worksAll Union Radio Orchestra / Nikolai GolovanovGolovanov's Scriabin cries, screams, rushes headlong into climaxes then collapses in a molten heap. These are old records, like sonically standard vintage soundtracks, but boy do they deliver. Rob Cowan More ... |  AcantusSacred and folk music from medieval ItalySacred 'songs of the people' from medieval Italy, in performances whose judicious mixture of earthiness and fine control have the power to touch you somewhere deep down. Medieval music at its most haunting and evocative. Lindsay Kemp More ... |
 Vycpálek: The Cantata of the Last Things of ManCzech Philharmonic Orchestra / Karel AncerlKarel Ancerl conducts this sombre dramatisation of death and transfiguration as though it was up there with Brahms and Strauss; and perhaps it should be. Peter Quantrill More ... |  Giordano: FedoraOlivero, del Monaco, Gobbi & Monreale / GardelliThe trio of Magda Olivero, Mario del Monaco and Tito Gobbi, under the baton of Lamberto Gardelli, give the piece for all it's worth, plus a bit more. Patrick O'Connor More ... |
 Bouzignac: Te Deum & MotetsLes Arts Florissants / William ChristieDon't begin to think this is just another French baroque disc . Lindsay Kemp More ... |  Donizetti: L'elisir d'amoreCarosio, Monti, Gobbi / SantiniEvery decade has provided strong competition, but this set stands up against them all. Patrick O'Connor More ... |
 Bellini: I Capuleti e i MontecchiBaker, Sills & Gedda / PatanèDame Janet Baker is the Romeo to the Juliet of Beverly Sills. Although there are now at least half a dozen other recordings, this retains a very special appeal, catching both great prima donnas towards the autumn of their stage careers but still in magnificent form. Patrick O'Connor More ... |  A Solo - Music for viola da gambaPaolo PandolfoOne of the most charismatic performers in Baroque music today, Pandolfo shows the full range of his sublime musicality in this tour of the solo viol repertoire. Lindsay Kemp More ... |
 Puccini: La BohèmeScotto, Poggi, Meneguzzer & Gobbi / VottoAntonino Votto conducts an irresistable performance. Despite its 45 years, this more than holds its own against starrier versions old and new. Patrick O'Connor More ... |  Beethoven: FidelioRysanek, Seefried, Haefliger, Fischer-Dieskau / FricsayFricsay's Fidelio "adds up", with fine singing that creates the impression of animated chamber music. Rob Cowan More ... |
 Monteverdi: VespersTaverner Consort, Andrew ParrottOne of Parrott's greatest achievements and still one of the finest Vespers ever despite strong recent competition, this superbly presented version catches an expert British cast of singers and players at a peak in their powers. Lindsay Kemp More ... |  Bach/Busoni: Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in CArthur Rubinstein (recorded 1934)This grand transcription may forever be associated with Vladimir Horowitz's 1965 historic return, yet his rival Arthur Rubinstein played it better for one of his least discussed and most incandescent recording sessions. Jed Distler More ... |