Schubert: Harfenspieler III 'Wer nie sein Brot mit Tränen ass', D480

“An attractive compilation from EMI's 2001-02 series of Schubert Lieder and piano music. Here, it's predominantly Lieder, with just three piano fragments; but with both artists at their relaxed and creatively focused best.” BBC Music Magazine, December 2008 ****

“...from Bostridge you have intelligent word painting, effortless sense of line, langorous phrasing, and a vocal quality that is as sonorous in the upper register as it is mellow in the lower. Andsnes more than accompanies, he pushes the beauty and depth of the piano writing to the fore, whilst never unbecomingly stealing the show.” Charlotte Gardner, bbc.co.uk, 11th July 2008

“Ian Bostridge is one of the most effective Schubert voices in Europe today” The Times

‘They brought their audience’s attention to more details in the Schubert Songs than any artists have before’ The Independent

“…this is one of the darkest, slowest Schwanengesangs on disc: there is a unique menace in the final 'Gute Nacht' of 'Kriegers Ahnung'; and 'In der Ferne' gives full, long weight to those six slow pulses within the last word of each line. Schreier's recital also offers consummate performances of Schubert's Goethe settings...” BBC Music Magazine, May 2006 *****

“The 1991 recital by Peter Schreier and András Schiff is highly desirable, though the sound is not quite on the same level. Schreier was never the most honeyed of tenors; but in the lighter songs of Schwanengesang he compensates for a touch of reediness and a tendency to harden on high notes with the supple grace of his phrasing and his ultra-keen response to the text. Liebesbotschaft is eager and volatile, enhanced by Schiff's wonderfully limpid touch and his care to make the piano's singing left hand match the voice in eloquence (Schubert's original, high, key an advantage, here and elsewhere).
On the downside, Aufenthalt is surely too slow and life-weary, weighed down by recurrent submissive rallentandos. But Das Fischermädchen has a lilting tenderness, Schiff again singing in dulcet partnership with the voice, while in the remaining Heine songs singer and pianist unflinchingly probe the extremes of anguish and bitterness. Die Stadt (the swirling, impressionistic arpeggios eerily insubstantial from Schiff) and Der Doppelgänger are as desolate and disturbing as any performances on disc, the suggestion of a whine, even a sneer, in Schreier's timbre extraordinarily apt here.
After this we get a sharply characterised Goethe group that encompasses the bleakness of the three Harper's Songs (done with characteristic intense immediacy) and ends with an impulsive, dancing Der Musensohn that rightly brings the house down.” Gramophone Classical Music Guide, 2010

“Schreier was never the most honeyed of tenors; but in the lighter songs of Schwanengesang he compensates for a touch of reediness and a tendency to harden on high notes with the supple grace of his phrasing and his ultra-keen response to the text. Liebesbotschaft is eager and volatile, enhanced by Schiff's wonderfully limpid touch and his care to make the piano's singing left hand match the voice in eloquence... Das Fischermädchen has a lilting tenderness, Schiff again singing in dulcet partnership with the voice... Die Stadt (the swirling, impressionistic arpeggios eerily insubstantial from Schiff) and Der Doppelgänger are as desolate and disturbing as any performances on disc...” Gramophone Magazine, July 2006

“Fischer-Dieskau is on top of his form...the spectrum of emotion takes on a new glow as each song begins...A treasurable disc” Penguin Guide, 2010 edition ***

“there is real intelligence [in Bastlein's singing]; a sense that he is viewing each song as a unity and as a miniaturised drama in its own right. As a first taste of what the series might offer in future installments it is certainly the most intriguing.” The Guardian, 7th January 2000