Rameau: Premier Livre de pièces de clavecin (1706): suite in A minor

“Gutman's playing is sensitive, lightly articulated and cautious in its expressive range. At times he errs on the side of understatement. It is, though, engaging for its ornamental delicacy and communicative lyricism.” BBC Music Magazine, December 2007 ****

“Rameau on the piano is gaining fast. …while the texture can still get congested on occasion, the overall feel is one of languid grace and charm. Gutman… achieves satisfying clarity and attack in many of the faster dance movements and reacts well to Rameau's strong harmonic sense, forcefully direct in places, deliciously clouded in others.” Gramophone Magazine, November 2007

"I like the unequal temperament tuning and superb timbre of the Clayson & Garrett instrument, the magnificent recording, and last but not least, Trevor Pinnock's playing which is as persuasive as it is scholarly" BBC CD Review

“The release of a CD devoted to Rameau's harpsichord music is relatively rare. But it's less Rameau, and much more French keyboard music in general, that suffers neglect from an over-cultivated image. However, if Rameau's music is highly allusive, it's also possessed of an immediacy that makes it approachable today. Sophie Yates's firmly grounded yet sensitive and spirited playing will quickly dispel any lingering reservations, and she writes with authority and charm in the accompanying booklet (and plays here a copy of a 1749 Goujon harpsichord made by Andrew Garlick).
Yates's astute selection from Rameau's output is bound to please. The first suite, in A minor, is from the book of Pièces de clavecin published shortly after Rameau arrived in Paris in 1706, and displays a youthful brilliance that relies heavily on ornamentation (as, for example, in the Allemande 1 and the Courante) and, delightfully, occasionally reveals a certain provincialism – although Rameau never travelled to Italy, he clearly made certain assumptions about life there: his 'La Vénitienne' makes particular allusion to the beggars' bagpipe and hurdy-gurdy.
The second and third suites, from his later book of 1724 (rev 1731), are altogether more stylish and sophisticated. The E minor Suite begins sedately and with the gravitas befitting an Allemande, but is otherwise shot through with fashionable, pastoral rondeaux, and includes two of Rameau's best-known party pieces, 'Le rappel des oiseaux' and 'Tambourin'. The D minor Suite amuses with pièces de caractère (the flirtatious 'La follette', the devious 'Le lardon' and the pathetic 'La boiteuse') and amazes with the virtuosity of 'Les tourbillons' and 'Les Cyclopes'.
But only a player of Yates's calibre can address the musical subtleties of 'Les soupirs', the deceptive 'Les niais de Sologne' and the sensuous 'L'entretien des muses'. A tour de force in every sense.” Gramophone Classical Music Guide, 2010