Wagner: Die Walküre (The Valkyrie)

“This cast is a mixture of international Wagnerians and Covent Garden residents, with the Wotan (Hotter), Siegfried (Windgassen) and Siegmund (Vinay) common to the 1955 Bayreuth set. The glory here is Birgit Nilsson’s gleaming Brünnhilde, already 39 years old, but sounding youthful, touching and tireless. The set is a reminder of the strengths of the company at this period, with Joan Sutherland leading the Rhinemaidens.” Sunday Times, 29th June 2008 ***

“Perhaps Kempe's lyricism doesn't always measure up completely to the darker moments in the drama. There's more anguish to be found in Walküre, for instance, than he allows, more bleakness in Götterdämmerung, and the recording quality is at best acceptable. But the virtues of this set far outweigh the drawbacks, and the best of it is gloriously compelling.” The Guardian, 30th May 2008 ****

“In short, Kempe's humane, often poetic Ring nourishes the spirit.” BBC Music Magazine, August 2008 ****

“the cast...[is] headed by Astrid Varnay as a wonderfully warm Brünnhilde and Hans Hotter as Wotan, his sound even more languidly beautiful than it is on the 1956 cycle conducted by Keilberth...Krauss's conducting is the main interest here – more sensuous, more concerned with orchestral sonority than Keilberth, though sometimes at the expense of dramatic clarity.” The Guardian, 30th September 2010 ***

“[Krauss] favours a more transparent sound than Furtwängler and faster-moving tempi which give his Ring integrity, propulsion and unusual clarity...Hotter's towering dramatic portait of Wotan...[is] a linchpin of the Krauss cycle...Erich Witte's slyly articulated, sardonic Loge and Paul Kuen's rivetingly sung - not yelled or whined - Mime are both outstanding too...this Ring is a true collector's item and it is good to have it in Orfeo's handsome 13-disc presentation” International Record Review, April 2011

“During the pioneering post-war era at Bayreuth the conducting of the Ring was shared among the Ks – Karajan, Krauss, Knappertsbusch, Keilberth and Kempe. These conductors collectively had a knowledge and experience of the cycle not equalled before or since, with the sole exception of their contemporary Furtwängler, who returned after the war only to conduct Beethoven's Ninth.
Although they were brought up in the same, exemplary tradition, the Ks had very different ways of treating the Ring, as you can now discover given the availability of so many cycles on CD. Krauss in his superb 1953 cycle went for a lean, dramatic, often electrifying and elating approach. He shared the cycles with Keilberth in 1953 after Karajan refused to return to Bayrreuth, and was scheduled to return in 1954. His sudden death left Keilberth solely in charge in 1954 and '55. We now have the elusive Keilberth cycle of 1955 from Testament, a version recorded by Decca but never issued. This now becomes the first stereo recording.
In 1956 Knappertsbusch, who had shared the 1951 cycles with Karajan returned to give what is generally agreed to be his most successful reading, taken as a whole. Unlike Krauss, Karajan and to a lesser extent Keilberth, the older conductor took a more measured view of the scores overall, one based on his preference for the long paragraph, well defined, almost pawky rhythms, and prominent ritardandi at points not always indicated in the score. At moments he seems to lose focus and let things run their own way where ensemble is concerned but, as a whole, especially in Rheingold and Götterdämmerung, his epic view of the score is almost unsurpassed. Even in the two middle operas there are moments of alternating quiet reflection and earthy energy that are very special.
He has at his command an ensemble of dedicated singers who had built their characterisations to a peak of achievement by 1956. Practically all are German-speaking and all have the art of acting with their voices in an immediate and communicative way, not to forget that they each had voices of a Wagnerian power too seldom found today.
Throughout Rheingold astonishment and delight are responses once more to the frightening power and presence of Gustav Neidlinger's trenchantly sung Alberich and by the detail, feeling and vocal authority of Hans Hotter's unsurpassed Wotan. Beside them an erstwhile Siegfried, Ludwig Suthaus, offers a Loge who gives every word, even syllable a distinctive colour and meaning, while Jean Madeira's Erda emits other-worldly authority.
And any Rheingold that boasts Josef Traxel, then a leading lyric tenor in Germany, as Froh has a bonus.
Four singers heard in later operas are introduced here. Paul Kuen, another familiar figure, is Mime and provides character without exaggeration.
Georgine von Milinkovic introduces us to an imperiously nagging Fricka and comes into her own in the next work. Josef Greindl is a formidable if unsubtle Fasolt, later a granite Hunding and a fearsome Hagen: no wonder, given so much work to do, he sometimes tires a little. Gré Brouwenstijn, a properly worried Freia, then gives us a Sieglinde who develops, in glorious tones, from an introvert to an extrovert when love strikes her. Beside her is Wolfgang Windgassen, standing in at the last moment for an ailing Vinay, and singing a Siegmund who is at once bel canto in line yet intensely eloquent.
Incredibly, the next evening he is a tirelessly effective Siegfried.
Hotter is magnificent in Wotan's Act 2 monologue, here made to seem at the very heart of the whole cycle, and as ever deeply moving in his Act 3 Farewell, forgiving signs of vocal weariness at the start of the act. By then we have met and admired Astrid Varnay's very womanly yet Opera Wagner 1278 heroic Brünnhilde. She occasionally overdoes the histrionics but by and large she has the character in her voice and bones in a way few other dramatic sopranos have managed.
In Siegfried Hotter manages ideally the humour of his Act 1 colloquy with Mime, his face-off with Neidlinger's Alberich in Act 2, and his desperation when meeting Madeira's implacable Erda at the start of Act 3. The awakening of Brünnhilde is not one of the conductor's best moments but the lovers give their all in the closing duet.
All the momentous climaxes of the cycle's finale find Kna at his most potent and involved, just as in 1951, and Varnay seconds him with her projection of all Brünnhilde's joy and sorrow. She also – incredibly – took on the Third Norn, at very short notice, Mödl having been taken suddenly ill. Madeira is heard again to advantage as both First Norn and Waltraute – would any singer do both today? Act 2 is simply tremendous. In this work Brouwenstijn returns as a vocally comely Gutrune, and Hermann Uhde, as in all the 1950s cycles, is an unsurpassed Gunther. With the Immolation one rightly feels that the earth has moved and that one has been through a lifeenhancing experience, which is as it should be.
Music & Arts issued this cycle in 1998 but this is the first issue with the Bayreuth imprimatur, though the sound quality is only marginally superior here. Orchestral textures are sometimes muted but that has much to do with the opera house's layout. No texts or translations but a good booklet, which quotes one contemporary critic as saying this was undoubtedly the Festival's greatest moment to date. Allegiance to the 1953 Krauss set is not altered but there is much here that remains unsurpassed.” Gramophone Classical Music Guide, 2010

“…Knappertsbusch… took a more measured view of the scores overall, one based on his preference for the long paragraph, well defined, almost pawky rhythms, and prominent ritardandi… At moments he seems to lose focus and let things run their own way where ensemble is concerned but, as a whole, especially in Rheingold and Götterdämmerung, his epic view of the score is almost unsurpassed. Even in the two middle operas there are moments of alternating quiet reflection and earthy energy that are very special. He has at his command an ensemble of dedicated singers who had built their characterisations to a peak of achievement by 1956.” Gramophone Magazine, February 2006